Ottos Pub & Brewery

Menu

Click Here to See TODAY’S FEATURES

Click here to view our MENU (see below too) as a PDF file

 

APPETIZERS

HOUSE MADE BEER PRETZEL (Vegan) (Otto’s Favorites)

With Roger’s almost famous sweet hot mustard (Vegetarian) 5.
Add Hogs Galore meats and Amish cheeses 7.

CHEESE FONDUE (Vegetarian)

Traditional fondue, made with local cheeses and Otto’s beer – served with toasted torta bread 8.
Add house made beer pretzel 2.

PIEROGIES

Sauteed with caramelized onions, bacon and sour cream 6.
Buffalo style – your choice of sauce and gorgonzola crumbles 7.

BEER BATTERED PICKLES

Dill pickle planks fried in our Spruce Creek Lager beer batter – served with Roger’s mustard. 6.

PEPPERONI ROLL (Otto’s Favorites)

House made pizza roll stuffed with cheese and pepperoni – served with a side of house made tomato sauce 8.

TOFU WINGS (Vegan)

Tofu fried crispy and tossed with your choice of BBQ, Thai Peanut or Garlic Sesame wing sauce – served with celery. 6.

HOUSE SMOKED CHICKEN THIGHS (Otto’s Favorites)

Three house smoked chicken thighs with your choice of sauce (sauce on side) – served with bleu cheese and celery 7.

CHICKEN WINGS

Six regular, or smoked (sauce on the side), or 6 oz. of boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce – served with bleu cheese and celery 7.

SAUCES

Garlic Sesame
Apple BBQ
Mango Habanero
Mild Buffalo
Thai Peanut (Spicy)
Sweet ‘n’ Spicy Garlic (Spicy)
Hurricane Mary (Spicy)
Brother Rod’s (Spicy)

NACHOS

Tri-color corn tortilla chips with beer cheese sauce, chili, jalapenos , black olives, pico de gallo, sour cream and guacamole 9.

QUESADILLA (Vegetarian)

Filled with cheddar jack cheese, grilled onions and peppers – served with sour cream and salsa 7.
Add black beans 1.
Add guacamole 1
Add chili 2.
Add pulled pork 3.
Add pulled chicken 3.
Add steak 6.

LOADED BAKED POTATO CHIPS

Fresh potato chips baked with cheddar jack cheese and bacon, topped with scallions and southwest ranch 7.

PEEL AND EAT SHRIMP

Shrimp steamed in our Spruce Creek Lager with garlic and fresh parsley – served wtih cocktail sauce and sourdough bread
1/2 lb. 12.  OR  1 lb. 20.

CREOLE CRAB DIP (Otto’s Favorites)

Blend of cream cheese, spices and sweet crab meat – served warm with house made baguette 8.
Add house made beer pretzel 2.

BEER CHEESE (Vegetarian)

A blend of Amish cheeses, cream cheese, herbs and our Spruce Creek Lager – served chilled with toasted torta bread 7.
Add house made beer pretzel 2.

BEER BATTERED FRIES (Vegan)

Regular 3.

SWEET POTATO FRIES (Vegan)

Dusted with cinnamon and ginger 4.

SALADS

Add portobello 4. (Vegan)
Add tofu 4(Vegan)
Add vegan walnut burger 5. (Vegan)
Add chicken breast 5.
Add pulled pork 5.
Add salmon 6.
Add steak 6.
Add crab cake 8.

HOUSE MADE DRESSINGS

Cranberry Orange Vinaigrette (Vegan)
Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan)
Thai Peanut (Vegan)
Bleu Cheese (Vegetarian)
Buttermilk Ranch (Vegetarian)
Russian (Vegetarian)
Smoky Honey Mustard (Vegetarian)
Southwest Ranch (Vegetarian)
Caesar (contains anchovy)

ENTREE HOUSE SALAD (Vegan)

Mixed greens with shaved Brussels sprouts, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, and tomatoes – choice of dressing 7.

COBB SALAD

Organic mixed greens, Hogs Galore bacon, roasted chicken breast, avocado, hard-boiled egg, tomatoes and gorgonzola crumbles – choice of dressing 12.

ROASTED BEET AND AMISH FETA SALAD (Vegetarian)

Arugula, beets, Amish feta cheese, apples, walnuts, and quinoa – with Cranberry Orange Vinaigrette 10.

BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD

Boneless wings tossed with choice of sauce, atop organic mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, tomatoes and gorgonzola cumbles – with bleu cheese dressing 12.

THAI SALAD (Vegan)

Organic mixed greens, cilantro, vermicelli noodles, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes and red onions – with Thai peanut dressing 8.

BURGERS

All burgers are served with beer battered fries – substitute sweet potato fries, vegetable of the day, starter House salad, starter Caesar salad or cup of chili for 2.  Soup of day – priced daily. 

HOUSE MADE DRESSINGS: Cranberry Orange Vinaigrette (Vegan), Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan), Thai Peanut (Vegan), Bleu Cheese (Vegetarian), Buttermilk Ranch (Vegetarian), Russian (Vegetarian), Smoky Honey Mustard (Vegetarian), Southwest Ranch (Vegetarian), Caesar (contains anchovy)

1/4 lb. or 1/2 lb. burgers are served on your choice of a toasted house made roll or toasted house made onion roll. We can prepare your 1/2 lb. burger with a red, pink or no pink center. All 1/4 lb. burgers will be served with a no pink center.

COWBOY BURGER (Otto’s Beef)

Topped with BBQ sauce, Hogs Galore bacon, stoutie onions, and cheddar cheese  8./12.

POLISH BURGER (Otto’s Beef)

Topped with pierogies, sour cream, caramelized onions, bacon and cheddar cheese 8./12.

OTTONATOR BURGER (Otto’s Beef)

Topped with house made pancetta, grilled onions and Amish white cheddar cheese   8./12.

ARTHURNATOR BURGER (Otto’s Beef)

Topped with avocado and Amish pepper jack cheese   8./12.

BUILD-A-BURGER (Otto’s Beef)

Choose from a 1/4 lb. or 1/2 lb. beef burger, chicken breast or vegan walnut burger. Select toppings from the choices below.
1/4 lb.   6.
1/2 lb.  10.
Chicken Breast  8.
Vegan Walnut Burger  8.

FREE TOPPINGS

Cajun spices, lettuce, sliced tomato, sliced red onion, banana peppers, cucumbers, jalapenos, pickle planks, ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise.

TOPPINGS each 1.00

American, Swiss, Cheddar, Provolone, sauteed onions, sauteed mushrooms, chili, mango black bean salsa, pierogies.

UBER TOPPINGS each 1.50

Amish Pepper Jack, Amish Smoked Cheddar, Amish Sharp White Cheddar, gorgonzola, fresh mozzarella, Hogs Galore bacon, pulled pork, house-made pancetta, avocado slices, stoutie onions.

SANDWICHES

All sandwiches are served with beer battered fries – substitute sweet potato fries, vegetable of the day, starter House salad, starter Caesar salad or cup of chili for 2.  Soup of day – priced daily.

CHEESESTEAK (Otto’s Beef) Otto’s Favorites)

With grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms and provolone cheese – served on house made beer infused grinder roll
Smoked brisket   11.
Chicken  9.
Portobello  (Vegetarian) 9.

PULLED PORK SANDWICH (Otto’s Favorites)

House smoked Hogs Galore pork shoulder with stoutie onions on a house made roll – served with coleslaw and choice of sauce  10.

SAUCES: Garlic Sesame, Apple BBQ, Mango Habanero, Mild Buffalo, Thai Peanut (Spicy), Sweet ‘n’ Spicy Garlic (Spicy), Hurricane Mary (Spicy), Brother Rod’s (Spicy)

THAI PB&J (Spicy) (Vegetarian)

Spicy Thai peanut butter and sweet Thai chili jam with an Asian-style slaw pressed between toasted flatbread  8.

HOT ITALIAN SAUSAGE SANDWICH (Spicy)

Hogs Galore Italian sausage with grilled onions and peppers – served on a house made, beer infused grinder roll with a side of marinara 10.

BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP

Seasoned strips of chicken breast, fried then tossed in your choice of sauce, with lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber and bleu cheese – rolled in a flour tortilla  9.

SAUCES: Garlic Sesame, Apple BBQ, Mango Habanero, Mild Buffalo, Thai Peanut (Spicy), Sweet ‘n’ Spicy Garlic (Spicy), Hurricane Mary (Spicy), Brother Rod’s (Spicy)

GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SANDWICH

Grilled marinated chicken breast atop romaine lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing and parmesan cheese – served on house made rosemary focaccia bread  10.

SOUTHWESTERN BLACK BEAN BURGER (Vegan)

House made with walnuts, vegan bacon, oats, mushrooms, onions, rice and black beans – topped with mango black bean salsa and sliced avocado – served on a house made torta roll  9.

REUBEN

Choice of corned beef, tempeh or house smoked turkey on rye – topped with Russian dressing, Swiss cheese and your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw  10.

ULTIMATE WEDGE

Beer infused dough baked with smoked turkey, ham, bacon, and provolone cheese – topped with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and southwest ranch. 12.

FISH TACOS (Spicy)

Two soft taco shells with southwest ranch, shredded lettuce and pico de gallo
Beer-battered cod  10.
Grilled swordfish  13.

LAMB GYRO (Otto’s Favorites)

Tender strips of lamb, shredded lettuce, tomato and tzatziki sauce stuffed in naan bread  10.

BACON-WRAPPED MEATLOAF SANDWICH (Otto’s Beef)

A thick slice of our homemade bacon-wrapped meatloaf on rosemary focaccia bread, smothered with roasted pepper chutney and horseradish aioli 12.

BLACK BEAN BURRITO (Vegetarian) (Otto’s Favorites)

Grilled onions, peppers, ranchero beans, rice, Amish smoked cheddar cheese and Amish pepper jack cheese – rolled in a grilled flour tortilla – served with pico de gallo and sour cream  9.
Add guacamole 1.
Add tofu  2.
Add portobello  4.
Add pulled chicken  3.
Add pulled pork 3.
Add steak 6.

APPLE BBQ BRISKET SANDWICH (Otto’s Beef) (Otto’s Favorites)

Smoked brisket served on a telera roll with Apple BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, and stoutie onions 10.

TURKEY BACON AVOCADO WRAP (Spicy)

House smoked turkey, avocado spread, Hogs Galore bacon, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and garlic aioli – rolled in a flour tortilla  11.

CUBAN PANINI

Mojo marinated pork loin, sliced ham, dill pickles, Swiss cheese, and Roger’s mustard – pressed on a telera roll 10.

ADD A SIDE

Cole slaw  3.
Vegetable of the Day  3.
Mashed Potatoes  3.
Ranchero Beans  3.
Beer battered fries  3.
Sweet Potato Fries  4.
Stoutie Onions  4.
Mac ‘n’ Cheese  5.
Starter House Salad  4.
Starter Caesar Salad  4.

Consuming undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

PIZZA

Baked in our wood fired oven, our 10″ pizzas are made with beer infused dough and house made tomato sauce.  They’re great to share as an appetizer or perfect as a meal for one!

BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA

BBQ Sauce, Swiss Cheese, Hogs Galore bacon, and grilled chicken 12.

GREEK PIZZA

Lamb, feta cheese, garlic butter, Kalamata olives, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, sundried tomatoes, and oregano 12.

JALAPENO POPPER PIZZA (Spicy)

Fresh jalapenos, bacon, cream cheese ranch sauce, and blended cheeses – topped with bread crumbs 12.

BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA (Spicy)

Bleu cheese, pulled chicken, celery, red onions and Hurricane Mary sauce  12.

HOGONATOR PIZZA (Otto’s Favorites)

Hogs Galore Italian sausage, bacon, and pepperoni with marinara, mozzarella, and a blend of cheeses  12.

WHITE PIZZA (Vegetarian)

Mozzarella, Parmesan and oregano on our house-made pizza dough with garlic butter 10.

BUILD-A-PIZZA

All build-a-pizzas come with your choice of one sauce, and a blend of cheeses.  Select toppings from the choices below – limit four toppings.  9. (Base price, then add topping costs)

SAUCE — (cost included)

Tomato sauce (Vegan)
Extra Virgin olive oil
Bleu Cheese dressing
Cream Cheese Ranch
Apple BBQ sauce 
Garlic Butter

VEGETABLE TOPPINGS — each 1.

Bananas peppers, black olives, broccoli, bell peppers, sauteed onions, jalapenos, Kalamata olives, mushrooms, pineapple, red onions, roasted red peppers, sliced tomatoes

UBER TOPPINGS — each 1.50

Pepperoni, pulled chicken, Hogs Galore bacon, Hogs Galore ham, Hogs Galore sausage, house smoked pulled pork, portobello mushroom, fresh mozzarella, tofu

PASTA

Add a starter House salad or starter Caesar salad to any pasta dish 2.

HOUSE MADE DRESSINGS: Cranberry Orange Vinaigrette (Vegan), Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan), Thai Peanut (Vegan), Bleu Cheese (Vegetarian), Buttermilk Ranch (Vegetarian), Russian (Vegetarian),  Smoky Honey Mustard (Vegetarian), Southwest Ranch (Vegetarian), Caesar (contains anchovy)

MAC ‘N’ CHEESE

Fasta radiatori pasta with Amish sharp and smoked cheddar cheeses, bacon and heavy cream – topped with seasoned bread crumbs  11.
Add tofu 4.
Add portobello 4.
Add chicken breast  5.
Add pulled pork 5.
Add vegan walnut burger 5.
Add salmon 6.
Add steak 6.
Add a crab cake 8.

BUFFALO CHICKEN MAC  ‘N’ CHEESE (Otto’s Favorites)

Boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce, incorporated into Fasta radiatori pasta with Amish sharp and smoked cheddar cheeses and heavy cream – topped with Amish cave aged bleu cheese  14.

SAUCES: Garlic Sesame, Apple BBQ, Mango Habanero, Mild Buffalo, Thai Peanut (Spicy), Sweet ‘n’ Spicy Garlic (Spicy), Hurricane Mary (Spicy), Brother Rod’s (Spicy)

PAD THAI (Vegan)

Pad Thai rice noodles tossed with almond butter, tamarind, maple syrup, sriracha, lime, ginger and peanut sauce, topped with chopped cilantro 8.
Add tofu 4.
Add portobello 4.
Add chicken breast  5.
Add pulled pork 5.
Add vegan walnut burger 5.
Add salmon 6.
Add steak 6.
Add a crab cake 8.

SEAFOOD PASTA

Seared mussels, bay scallops, and shrimp tossed with fettuccine and lobster cream sauce – served with torta bread  18.

ENTREES

Available all day. All entrees come with vegetable of the day and your choice of whipped potatoes, beer battered fries, sweet potato fries or wild rice.

Add a starter House salad or starter Caesar salad to any entree  2.

HOUSE MADE DRESSINGS: Cranberry Orange Vinaigrette (Vegan), Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan), Thai Peanut (Vegan), Bleu Cheese (Vegetarian), Buttermilk Ranch (Vegetarian), Russian (Vegetarian),  Smoky Honey Mustard (Vegetarian), Southwest Ranch (Vegetarian), Caesar (contains anchovy)

RIBEYE (Otto’s Beef)

12 oz. Ribeye – char grilled to temperature  and finished with a mushroom bacon ragout 20.

SUGAR CURED NEW YORK STRIP (Otto’s Beef)

12 oz. sugar-cured New York Strip – char grilled to temperature and finished with a medallion of bourbon chive butter 20.

ST. LOUIS RIBS

Hogs Galore St. Louis ribs, grilled to perfection and smothered in our apple BBQ sauce 15.

CHICKEN AND WAFFLES (Otto’s Favorites)

Pennsylvania Dutch style comfort food! Pulled tender chicken, and hearty yellow gravy over thick Amish style waffles 12.

CARIBBEAN CRAB CAKE

Jumbo lump crab cakes over a mango black bean salsa  (1) 13.  OR (2) 18.

SPRUCE CREEK BEER BATTERED FISH (Otto’s Favorites)

Cod filets, beer battered with Spruce Creek Lager, served with coleslaw and remoulade sauce  14.

MAPLE GLAZED SALMON

Grilled salmon basted and glazed with maple syrup, brown sugar, and spices – served on a bed of wild rice 20.

BACON WRAPPED MEATLOAF DINNER (Otto’s Beef)

A generous helping of our house made bacon wrapped meatloaf – served with Red Mo gravy 12.

ADD A SIDE

Cole slaw  3.
Vegetable of the Day  3.
Mashed Potatoes  3.
Ranchero Beans  3.
Beer battered fries  3.
Sweet Potato Fries  4.
Stoutie Onions  4.
Mac ‘n’ Cheese  5.
Starter House Salad  4.
Starter Caesar Salad  4.

Back to top